The worst Georgette Heyer cover EVER?

The other day, I was talking with a friend. We both enjoy Regency romances. We’ve read scores of them over the decades. And we were joking about some of the horrid covers that some otherwise good books sport.

She pointed out something that I hadn’t thought of. The books usually feature the heroine on the cover, and while the cover artists wouldn’t dream of putting a Regency heroine in a miniskirt or blue jeans, the woman inside the clothes matches the period the book was published rather than the Regency period. So you’ll see a young lady from an era where only ‘lightskirts’ wore makeup, and she’s got bright pink lips and blue eyelids.

I went back and looked at my Regency collection, some bought new and some gleaned from the finest used book stores from coast to coast. And I came across what must be the all-time worst cover of a Georgette Heyer.

Now, when it comes to Regencies, Heyer is the gold standard. She invented the genre. She set the standard that a Regency is not just a romance set in a particular time period, but is a book with a certain tone, light-hearted and with a good seasoning of humor. The best of the rest are praised as ‘almost as good as Heyer’.

And among the Heyers, one of the best is Sylvester, or The Wicked Uncle. To refresh your memory (because of course you’ve read it!), the heroine, Phoebe, is a shy young lady with mousy brown hair, whose London Season was an uninteresting flop.

My copy of Sylvester appears to be the first US paperback edition. Yes, from the 1950s.  And without further ado, here is the Worst Heyer Cover Ever:



Mousy little Phoebe, a glamorous blonde in 50s era eyeliner? I wouldn’t call the clothes exactly Regency either – three-quarters sleeves? That’s 50s, not Regency.

And that… that… HAT! It’s not Regency, it’s not 50s – was there ever a time in human history when that Hat-like Thing was fashionable?

The whole thing reminds me of a movie poster from an alternate universe. Say – Breakfast At Tiffany’s – starring Doris Day.



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “The worst Georgette Heyer cover EVER?

  1. Book covers, and the decisions on what to do thereof, are one of the biggest challenges of any author, and if not done right, it haunts us forever. To me, it’s like adding the right icing to the cake. My book cover was done in desperation; the shadow box, my crackerjack top, and the white lace tablecloth where I dumped the acoutraments and snapped the shot….it was worth the haste.

  2. Liz

    I own that horrible Sylvester cover, too! To me it also looks like a distorted version of a “My Fair Lady” album cover. Sadly, the dog is the best-drawn character. Adorable, although totally irrelevant.

    • You might be onto something. The movie of MFL came out a year before Sylvester, so maybe the publishers were trying to ping the book buyers’ subconscious memory, make them think ‘if you liked My Fair Lady…’

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s